Egyptian “Gay Rights Activist,” or Ex-Gay Proponent?

Cover of Ahmed Saad's controversial novel on Egyptian gay men

An article (“Lady Boys: A defense of Egyptian homosexuals?) in today’s English-language version of Al-Masry Al-Youm, an independent Egyptian newsletter, reviews journalist Ahmed Saad’s new novel, Shab Takaya, about life for gay men in Egypt. Saab is “a self-proclaimed gay rights activist,” though a closer look at his work reveals that his use of the term is questionable.

A little background: Male homosexuality is illegal in Egypt, and punishable with prison terms of up to 10 years. In 2001, 52 men were arrested at a gay discotheque in Cairo and charged with “obscene behavior.” The case of the so-called “Cairo 52,” widely publicized in internationally, became a symbol for intolerant attitudes toward gays in Egypt and, more broadly, the Islamic world.

The book reviewer describes Saad’s book as “the first Egyptian book that seeks to defend homosexuals on the basis of Islam,” but admits that it “offers a complex and seemingly contradictory perspective.” The book’s intention is to “convince its intended audience–heterosexuals in Egyptian society–to sympathize with the plight of Egypt’s homosexuals and put an end to their societal persecution.”

Since Saad’s book has been seriously suppressed in Egypt, it is unclear whether the work will be widely read or have much effect on the way Egyptian society perceives gay men. But if it Saad’s message were to reach Egyptian society, would it be a positive or negative influence?

In some ways, Saad’s book does represent progress, and a significant breakthrough. Saad’s stance is much more compassionate than other responses to homosexuality in Egypt and the broader Islamic world – executing, imprisoning, or ostracizing gays – but Saad’s viewpoint could hardly be characterized as a defense of gay people.

Saad claims that his “merciful approach” to homosexuality is based on the Qu’ran. This approach is, in a word, Repent.

Based on the writings of the Quran, many Muslims believe that homosexuality is a crime punishable by death. Saad sees this attitude as a disastrous textual misinterpretation, and reminds us that God only punishes those who refuse to atone for their sins. Instead of condemning homosexuals, Saad told Al-Masry Al-Youm, we must “adopt a merciful approach and help them to repent.”

Nevertheless, the book suggests the possibility that homosexuals may be executed if they refuse to commit to a heterosexual way of life. If you think homosexuals should be persecuted, he writes, “don’t forget that God” waited until “after they refused his guidance to sentence them to death.”

The “merciful approach” that Saad is advocating is that homosexuals should be given a chance to repent – and then, if they don’t, they should be executed.

The article then confirms that Saad does indeed support the execution of homosexuals who don’t repent after they are offered the option of doing so:

Saad explicitly confirmed what the book merely implies. “As the homosexuals of Sodom and Ghomorra were executed because they didn’t heed God’s words, homosexuals should be ‘stoned to death,’ as Islam decrees, if they refuse to reform,” he said.

This hardly seems like the words one would expect from “a self-proclaimed gay rights activist.” The idea that homosexuals can and should change, and that “every gay man deserves a second chance at heterosexuality,” has a twin in the West: the ex-gay movement. (“Ex-gay” programs, most of which are religiously based, attempt to change gay, lesbian, and bisexual people into heterosexuals.)

Does Saad’s stance represent a step in a positive direction for gay men in Egypt? In some ways, yes – he advocates for some degree of social tolerance and compassion. But calling for people to change their sexual orientation is by no means a compassionate approach. If the ex-gay movement in the West is any gauge, religious programs that attempt to change a person’s sexual orientation can be extremely harmful. Peterson Toscano, a survivor of several ex-gay programs in the United States, describes some of the ways that ex-gay programs can harm people: emotionally, psychologically, spiritually, relationship-wise, financially, sexually, physically, and career-wise, among others. There are also some serious doubts as to whether these programs actually work. In 2009, the American Psychological Association adopted a resolution condemning “reparative therapy.”

Does Saad, a supposed activist, truly speak for gay men in Egypt? The book review reports that Saad’s book has come under criticism from “homosexuals who believe that the writer’s ideas only serve to further stigmatize them.” This is not surprising – after all, Saad advocates execution for gays who refuse to change. Despite being described as a “gay rights activist,” Saad “said during the interview that there is no such thing as an individual right to homosexuality.”

While Saad’s position on homosexuality is far from affirming, it might still do a small amount of good for gay men in Egypt. The most positive way to view Saad’s stance toward homosexuality might be through the lens of a harm-reduction model, as applied to homophobia: “a set of … strategies that reduce negative consequences of” homophobia.

However, Saad’s recommendations for dealing with homosexuality should come with a warning label: Attempting to change sexual orientation may result in more harm than good. And anyone who advocates for the execution of gay people is not, by any stretch, a gay rights activist.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Egyptian “Gay Rights Activist,” or Ex-Gay Proponent?

  1. Pingback: Too Many Straight Cooks in the LGBTQ Kitchen. Ep 38 Queer and Queerer « Peterson Toscano's A Musing

  2. Doug EG says:

    We very much hope for a peaceful transition to a consensus government with more political, economic, and social freedom and justice for the Egyptian people. It is too early to tell whether Dr. ElBaradei may be a good leader in this regard, and of course it’s up to the Egyptians to assess and decide.
    ElBaradei’s talk of human rights sounds good, but an excellent litmus test of how much he truly believes in human rights for all, and a question I’ve seen no one in the media ask him, is: Does all your talk of human rights include gay rights?!
    Will you END Egypt’s repressive, belligerent, even violent anti-gay policies?
    Where do Egyptian gay rights advocates stand regarding Dr. ElBaradei??

    • Axel Raafat says:

      That wouldn’t really help him when he runs for presidency if he does again since people won’t vote for him because he’s for gay rights. It’s like what Obama did. He never said anything i believe about supporting gay marriage in his first time running for president. But in the second time he did win. But also the American people are more open minded than the egyptians. It’s because they have access to information and technology and aren’t poor so they’re more civilised. I’m muslim and i don’t mind gay rights. I don’t hate gay people. I don’t care about gay people. They can do whatever they want but i ofcourse would find it disturbing if i see 2 men kissing in the park but that’s just merely because i’m straight and i do not find that pleasing to the eye but that does not give me the right to take away their freedom and also i don’t mind knowing gay people aslong as they do not hit on me. I don’t want to be hit on by gay men. It just disturbs me that out there there’s another man thinking about having sex with me. Again that’s how i feel but i’m all for gay rights but i’m not sure about Gay marriage since idk i think it’s a sacred thing. I don’t know in all honesty since i didn’t research the gay marriage part well yet or didn’t look it up but i’m not for gay marriage but i’m for gay rights other than marriage. 😀

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s